Saturday, August 03, 2024
Book Review: Forged in Crisis- a tough read, but worthwhile
When you read a concept, it shows up everywhere.
One of the 5 life journeys that have been detailed in ‘Forged in Crisis’ is
that of Frederick Douglass, who was an escaped slave who made significant
contributions to the anti-slavery movement. I was separately reading the useful
seeming NY Times list of best books of the 21st century that come
out recently, and lo and behold: in it features “Frederick Douglass: Prophet of
freedom”. Apparently, this biography also won the 2019 Pulitzer prize in
history.
Be warned that ‘Forged in Crisis’ is not an easy and smooth
read, definitely not a page turner. Maybe you get into a ‘crisis’ midway
through the book, when you are not able to progress. Then you eventually muster
up the will power to move ahead, and thus are you ‘forged’. The book requires
annotation, and a second reading. The book is a mini biography of 5 leaders-
Abraham Lincoln, Ernest Shackleton the south pole explorer, Rachel Carson the
scientist environmentalist who got DDT banned, Frederick Douglass who's described earlier, and Baunhoffer a German priest
who resisted Nazi-ism through his interpretations of Christianity.
All five lives in this book dealt with serious crises in
their lives. Matters of life and death. Crises large and small. Their sense of
adventure and breaking out from the norm is remarkable. Escaping slavery, providing
for a large family as a young sole breadwinning woman in the 1950s, finishing a
tour de force of writing and journalism while fighting cancer, marshalling men to
safety with limited resources near south pole, outspokenly fighting the nazis,
dealing with losses of sweetheart and son while having broken away from birth
family- these are experiences that can completely break someone who is not incredibly
strong internally. The fact that these famous five endured is testament to the
human will- it can endure so much hardship, yet emerge unbroken with solutions.
This concept of ‘dealing with struggles and failure’ showed
up in multiple places for me, on the lines of how Frederick Douglass did. In a conversation, M, a frequent acolyte, talked about how Indian
myths such as Mahabharata and Ramayana are all about the hero dealing with
serious adversity although in the popular tellings of the tales we don’t appreciate
or empathize with the hero. Rama having his wife stolen and then dealing with
life as a nomad as he tried to find her. Krishna, who forever wanted peace, failed
miserably in his quest for peace for after all he presided over a massive war. A
powerful tale of ‘giving’ and ‘failure’ from Abe Lincoln’s life is dramatically
told in the excellent book Give and Take (gotto read more of Adam Grant!). I
listened to a great podcast episode on parenting, on the reliably excellent
Huberman Labs podcast, this one starring parenting expert Doc Becky Kennedy. Doc
Becky stressed upon the importance of children learning the skill of dealing
with frustration and struggle, at a time when the world provides many conveniences
with minimal effort, such as movies on Netflix, food on Swiggy and essentials on
Zepto. Just yesterday, I was giving up hope when Lakshya Sen was down 5 points
vs TC Chou, with Chou seemingly outplaying him in the QFs of the Olympic
Singles badminton. That was some crisis. The way Lakshya came back was inspiring,
making him the first Indian male shuttler to the Olympic semis. ‘Comebacks’ being
bigger than the‘Setbacks’ is a mantra going on at work, given the tough time
our industry is facing.
The other interesting aspect which came through for me was
how the final position or perspective of the life in question was built over
time. Some of the 5 initially in their lives had no special interest or
willingness to build that grand perspective for which they have become famous. Therefore,
the word ‘forged’ in the title becomes apt.
The famous 5 also got swept up in something that is bigger
than themselves, and that gave them the strength to overcome hardship. At the end
of the second paragraph, I expressed awe about how they endured – and that’s how
it happened- they were bolstered by something much bigger than their own puny
selves. This concept I came across today as I heard a youtube video recommended
by Tim Ferris, a an interview of Joseph Campbell, the author of the book ‘Hero
with a thousand faces’ which is said to have inspired countless artists and
leaders. Campbell talked about the importance of the ‘struggle’ in the story of
the hero, and also about getting involved in a cause that was outside and
beyond their own limited ego. This makes the hero realize that their own ego is
small in the bigger picture. He is an instrument of a far bigger force, and they
draw power from that ‘force’. Especially in the context that the video was
describing Star Wars movies. All 5 people in this book ‘used the force’, the
force being contextual and customized to their circumstances.
The book details out the subject of emotional mastery, which
was mentioned in the book Awe whose review is my previous post in this blog, and
in the movie Inside Out which I rewatched recently. The author of Awe was a
consultant to the directing team of Inside out. He talks about how the ‘Inside’
in ‘Inside out’ means that our emotional experience of an event is driven by
which emotion is at the helm of the mental console inside us, and hints that we
should have the skill to enable the emotion we want to be at the helm when we
want. Doc Becky says that children deal with the entire maelstrom of emotions
as an adult, but don’t have the skill to deal with it.
The book produces some gems from time to time – ‘In moments
of great turbulence when the stakes are high, the fate of a particular
enterprise comes down- briefly and critically- to the energy and actions of the
individual leader’. This is mentioned about Shackleton, who is the Captain of
the endurance which is grounded in the South Pole. Sidenote: In one of my
favorite movies, Interstellar, the spaceship is named ‘Endurance’ putatively after Shackleton’s vessel. One more
gem, from the life of FD: ‘I lived more in that one day than I lived in a year’.
On a similar theme, about how certain moments get etched in memory, by Rachel
Carson when on her deathbed wrote a farewell letter to a friend: ‘For me it was
one of the loveliest of the summer’s hours, and all details will remain in my
memory; the blue September sky, the sounds of wind in the spruces and the surf
on the rock, the gulls busy with their foraging, alighting with deliberate
grace, the distant views of Griffith’s Head and Todd point, today so clearly
etched though once half seen in swirling fog.’
Multiple traits of leadership are touched upon through the 5
lives- cheerfulness and positive attitude during difficult times, creating ‘distance’
from a team, nimbleness in terms of goals to react to the environment. The
leader has to ‘define the crisis’ – first for themselves, and then for the
people involved. There’s a point around avoiding the ‘seduction of the single
definitive answer’. Except for Shackleton, four others are excellent communicators,
either oratorically or through the written word, or both. ‘Right action requires
taking a long pause and considering how one can do the most good. This always
entails putting one’s gifts and experience to their best use’. The ability to create
and sustain an effective community. Effectiveness as a human: Everyday
kindness, humour, humility and accessibility. The need to move beyond data and
facts to translate information into knowledge, knowledge to understanding, and
understanding to wisdom.
Those who live an adventurous life do various crazy things out
of the norm. When Lincoln reached ‘Springfield’, a colleague from state
legislature offered the newcome free meals at is Springfield home, and for five
years Lincoln ate there free of charge. Earlier in his life, at ‘New Salem’, he
took on wrestlers from a neighboring village in front of a large crowd. The
author Nancy uses a nice word to describe him- an ‘autodictat’ – one who learns
by himself. Lincoln shook hands with 6,000 patients at a hospital, after the
war. And after that as a show of strength, he chopped wood with an axe. A feat
which soldiers could not repeat. Bonhofffer, a priest in Nazi Germany and one
of the five, suddenly wonders , ‘his mind turned to Mahatma Gandhi, and he
wondered if the time had come for him to take a sabbatical in India’.
Although not its main thrust, the book satisfyingly dwells upon
other big themes such as history, religion and ecological conservation. Apparently,
Lincoln’s assassination stopped a clean healing process post the Civil war, and
the book speculates that even the current racial issues in US might have not
existed had Lincolns assassination not happened. Gurucharan Das expressed a view
about Gandhi’s untimely death, saying that Gandhi was the only ‘Liberal’ in
India who was not English speaking elite, and with his death the concepts of ‘liberalism’
did not reach the masses in India. When
it comes to religion, Bonhoffer redefines Christianity as ‘not focused on man’s
salvation after death but rather on man’s life on earth’, ‘deal with life and
goodness rather than death and guilt’. He came up with a ‘non religious’
interpretation of Christianity, which ‘presented man with the challenge to serve
those who are powerless, oppressed and reviled- in short, those who suffer’ .
In Rachel Carson’s life, we see how scientific temperament of the masses is
shaped by journalist-scientists such as Rachel Carson, and publications such as
Scientific American. I asked C, a relative and a prof at IIT, if such publications
and writers exist in India. He mentioned a publication from IISc, which we
scanned through and decided to be more technical than a layman would like.
Carson’s ‘The sea around us’ , which was a book on the wonders of marine life,
reached #1 on the New York bestseller list.
So, I recommend this book, but it won’t be smooth sailing. Apt, for that’s the situation Mr Shackleton encountered.
Labels: Books
Subscribe to Posts [Atom]